Determinists are a bunch of hippies
...was the
verbal shout from across the room/desk. My colleague's vision on
determinists. Are they hippies?
Maybe its
because there is an x in his last name, I don't know. But he has a
point.
Determinists
are people that believe that the universe is governed by solid,
deterministic laws. If you say you have free speech, they say it is
only input-based output of the brain. Everything is a reaction to a
cause. As the famous physicist Albert Einstein (No physics blog can
do without him) said: "God doesn't play dice". He meant
that there is no stochastic, chance-based effects in the world. The
Universe is deterministic.
However quantum
mechanical observations disapprove this. In the quantum mechanics
field, non-deterministic phenomenon are observed on a daily basis.
Take for example the Heisenberg principle. If you know the location
of the particle, you don't know its speed (exactly it is momentum,
but that is the same as velocity times mass, so we don't have to bother about the weight of the statement). My dad once tried to use this principle when he got
pulled over for speeding: "But officer, if you know I was driving
on this highway, how did you know my velocity?" Of course, this only works in micro-space, so the assumption of my dad was wrong and
the officer question exactly this part of his argumentation with a
large fine.
But there are
real scientific observations of this principle. Just Google
Heisenberg principle experimental observations and indulge yourself
in the quantum mechanics.
So where do the
hippies come in the picture. To be a determinist you have to follow
your gut and believe that in the end with infinite knowledge (a
very accurate initial state), the universe can be propagated in the
exact way. There is however no experiment to test this hypothesis.
You should build two exact universes, let them progress in time and
space and see if the follow the same path. This is not possible and
thus there remains room for intuition and believe. A determinists
believes there is no coincidence and disregards any
observation that has non-deterministic phenomenon just by
stating a lack of knowledge. They follow their intuition, like
hippies.
Reacties
Een reactie posten